What a Major U.S. Mortality Study Reveals About Faith, Community, and Survival
This article explores new evidence showing how social isolation and loss of community support are linked to deaths of despair—and why belonging matters for health.
🎧 ▶️ Press the play button below to listen in English.
🇨🇳 中文（简体）
本文探讨最新研究证据，说明社会孤立和社区支持的缺失如何与绝望之死相关，以及归属感为何对健康至关重要。
请按下方的播放按钮收听。
🇪🇸 Spanish (Latinoamérica)
Este artículo analiza nueva evidencia que muestra cómo el aislamiento social y la pérdida del apoyo comunitario se relacionan con las muertes por desesperación y la salud.
Presiona el botón de reproducir para escuchar.
Introduction: A Peer-Reviewed Warning We Can No Longer Ignore
When people talk about health risks, they usually mention smoking, obesity, high blood pressure, or diabetes. Rarely does anyone mention church attendance—yet a peer-reviewed, journal-published economic study now shows that declining participation in organized religion is linked to higher death rates from suicide, alcohol-related liver disease, and drug poisoning.
In November 2025, economists Tyler Giles, Daniel Hungerman, and Tamar Oostrom published their findings in the Journal of the European Economic Association, one of the most respected journals in the field. The paper, titled Deaths of Despair and the Decline of American Religion, is now formally published and available via Oxford University Press (DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jeea/jvaf048).
Using decades of U.S. mortality data and rigorous natural-experiment methods, the authors show that the modern rise in “deaths of despair” was preceded—not followed—by a sharp decline in religious participation, particularly church attendance. Even more striking, when policies reduced church attendance unintentionally, mortality from despair-related causes rose soon after Deaths_of_Despair_Giles_Hungerm….
In other words, this is no longer a speculative sociological theory. It is now peer-reviewed economic evidence suggesting that withdrawing from organized religious life—especially regular church attendance—can have measurable and, in some cases, fatal health consequences.
What Are “Deaths of Despair”?
“Deaths of despair” is a term used to describe mortality from:
- Suicide
- Drug poisonings
- Alcohol-related liver disease
These deaths rose so sharply among middle-aged Americans in the 1990s that they reversed decades of declining mortality—a historic anomaly in a wealthy country.
Most explanations focus on economics or opioids. But this study shows those explanations do not fully account for when and how the crisis began.
The Timeline That Changed Everything
One of the most striking findings is timing.
- Deaths of despair began rising in the early 1990s
- The opioid crisis (OxyContin) did not begin until 1996
- Economic downturns occurred later and inconsistently
What did happen first?
➡️ A steep national decline in church attendance and religious participation beginning in the late 1980s
This decline:
- Happened before mortality rose
- Occurred in the same states
- Affected the same demographic groups
Who Was Most Affected?
The strongest effects were seen in:
- Middle-aged adults (45–64)
- White Americans
- Those without a college degree
This group:
- Had higher church attendance than others in the 1970s
- Experienced the largest drop in attendance by the 1990s
- Later suffered the largest increase in deaths of despair
The overlap was not subtle—it was almost exact.
Natural Experiments: When Church Attendance Was Disrupted
To move beyond correlation, the researchers examined a powerful natural experiment: the repeal of Sunday “blue laws.”
These laws once restricted Sunday commerce, making church attendance easier and socially reinforced. When states repealed them:
- Church attendance dropped 5–10 percentage points
- Deaths of despair rose by ~2 per 100,000 people per year
- Other causes of death barely changed
This pattern strongly suggests cause and effect rather than coincidence.
Why Would Not Going to Church Increase Mortality?
The study explored several mechanisms.
1. Loss of Meaning and Structure
Church provides:
- Weekly rhythm
- Moral framework
- A sense of purpose beyond self
Removing that structure disproportionately harms middle-aged adults, whose social networks are already shrinking.
2. Weakening of Behavioral Guardrails
Church participation historically discourages:
- Heavy drinking
- Substance abuse
- Self-harm
After church attendance declined:
- Unsafe drinking increased
- Suicide risk rose
- Liver disease deaths followed
3. Loss of Mutual Support—Not Just “Socializing”
Interestingly, the study found no major decline in casual social activity (friends, neighbors, bars).
What declined was institutional support:
- Moral accountability
- Pastoral care
- Shared norms
- Crisis intervention before collapse
This suggests church is not replaceable by casual social contact.
A Sobering Calculation
The authors estimate that:
- A 10-percentage-point drop in weekly church attendance
- Leads to ~2 extra deaths per 100,000 middle-aged adults per year
- Meaning roughly 1 in 5,000 people who stop attending weekly church dies annually from a death of despair
That is not symbolic harm.
That is statistical mortality
Is This About Belief—or Participation?
Importantly, personal belief in God remained high during this period.
What changed was:
- Attendance
- Affiliation
- Belonging
This suggests the protective effect comes less from private belief and more from active participation in a moral, structured, and supportive community.
What This Means for Public Health
This study forces an uncomfortable conclusion:
Secularization is not health-neutral.
When large populations disengage from institutions that provide meaning, discipline, and mutual care, mortality can rise—even in the absence of war, famine, or depression.
Ignoring this factor leaves a major blind spot in our thinking about prevention.
Bottom Line
Not going to church is often framed as a personal lifestyle choice with no physical consequences.
The data say otherwise.
For millions of Americans—especially in midlife—leaving church was followed by rising despair, risky behavior, and premature death.
Faith, it turns out, may be as much a public-health issue as a private one.
Clinical Commentary: A Preventive-Medicine Perspective
From a preventive-medicine standpoint, the findings of Deaths of Despair and the Decline of American Religion are not surprising—they are clinically intuitive, even if rarely acknowledged in modern medicine
1. Church Attendance Functions as a Health-Protective Behavior
In clinical practice, prevention focuses on risk modifiers, not just diseases. Regular church attendance appears to function as one such modifier by influencing:
- Mental health (lower depression and suicide risk)
- Substance use (reduced alcohol and drug misuse)
- Behavioral regulation (sleep–wake rhythm, moderation, accountability)
- Social buffering against stress and isolation
From this lens, church attendance is not merely “spiritual”—it is behavioral medicine.
2. Middle Age Is a High-Risk Window
The study’s strongest effects were seen in adults aged 45–64, a group that clinicians already recognize as vulnerable due to:
- Shrinking social networks
- Work and financial stress
- Caregiving burden
- Early chronic disease (hypertension, prediabetes, fatty liver, depression)
When church participation declines during this life stage, the loss is not easily replaced. Younger adults still have peer networks; older adults may have Medicare, retirement structures, or community programs. Middle-aged adults often lack these buffers.
3. This Is Not About Theology—It’s About Structure
Clinically, what matters is not doctrine but structure:
- A fixed weekly schedule
- A non-negotiable pause from work
- Regular human contact
- Norms discouraging self-destruction
Preventive medicine already recognizes similar effects in:
- Exercise classes
- Cardiac rehab programs
- Alcohol recovery groups
Church attendance combines all of these in a single, low-cost intervention.
4. Why This Matters for Modern Medicine
Modern healthcare excels at:
- Prescribing medications
- Ordering tests
- Treating acute crises
But it is poor at restoring meaning, belonging, and restraint—precisely the domains most relevant to deaths of despair.
This study suggests that removing a long-standing protective institution without a replacement may unintentionally increase mortality, even in a technologically advanced society.
Counter-Arguments—and Why They Fall Short
Because this topic touches culture, religion, and policy, it predictably attracts criticism. The paper anticipates many of these objections—and the data address them directly.
Criticism 1: “This Is Just Correlation, Not Causation”
Response:
The authors go beyond correlation by using natural experiments—specifically, the repeal of Sunday blue laws. These policy changes:
- Reduced church attendance
- Were not driven by health trends
- Were followed by increases in deaths of despair
- Did not meaningfully affect other causes of death
This design strengthens causal inference well beyond simple observational studies.
Criticism 2: “It’s Really About Economics or Opioids”
Response:
The timeline does not support this claim:
- Deaths of despair began rising before the opioid crisis
- Major opioid drivers (like OxyContin) entered the market years later
- Economic downturns did not align consistently with the mortality shift
The study explicitly shows that the mortality break began in the early 1990s, when neither opioids nor major recessions could explain it.
Criticism 3: “Church Just Proxies for Socialization”
Response:
The authors tested this directly. After church attendance declined:
- Time spent with friends, neighbors, or relatives did not significantly decrease
- General social trust did not collapse
- Voting and civic engagement sometimes increased
This indicates that church-going is not interchangeable with casual social contact. It provides something qualitatively different—norms, meaning, restraint, and mutual responsibility.
Criticism 4: “Religion Can Be Harmful Too”
Response:
This is true—and irrelevant to the core finding.
The study does not claim religion is universally beneficial or free of harm. It shows that removing a deeply embedded social institution without a functional replacement has population-level health consequences.
Preventive medicine already accepts this logic in other domains:
- Abrupt withdrawal of structure increases relapse
- Loss of routine worsens depression
- Social isolation raises mortality risk
Religion is simply another structured system with measurable effects.
Criticism 5: “People Still Believe—They Just Don’t Attend”
Response:
Belief alone did not protect against mortality.
The study shows that:
- Private belief remained high
- Attendance and affiliation declined
- Mortality increased anyway
This distinction is crucial: participation, not belief, was protective.
Clinical Bottom Line
From a preventive-medicine perspective, this study delivers a clear message:
Institutions that provide structure, restraint, meaning, and mutual support can lower mortality—even when they are non-medical.
Ignoring this reality leaves clinicians and policymakers blind to a major, modifiable risk factor for despair-related deaths.
If medicine continues to focus only on prescriptions and procedures—while dismissing social and moral infrastructure—it should not be surprised when deaths of despair continue to rise.
Don’t Get Sick!
Medically Reviewed by Dr. Jesse Santiano, MD
Dr. Santiano is a retired internist and emergency physician with extensive clinical experience in metabolic health, cardiovascular prevention, and lifestyle medicine. He reviews all medical content on this site to ensure accuracy, clarity, and safe application for readers. This article is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for personal medical care.
💡 Support This Work
Creating well-researched articles, maintaining this website, and keeping the information free takes time and resources.
If you found this article helpful, please consider donating to support the mission of empowering people to live healthier, longer lives, without relying on medications.
🙏 Every contribution, big or small, truly makes a difference. Thank you for your support!
Follow me on Facebook, Gab, Twitter (formerly known as X), and Telegram.
Related:
- Saints Among Us: Uncovering the Relics of St. Felix and the Theban Legion
- Unlock Healing And Peace Through Mindfulness At Catholic Mass
- Fetal Microchimerism: How a Mother Carries Her Child’s Love Forever in Her Cells
- How Cold Exposure Strengthens Your Heart, Brain, And Resilience Naturally
Reference:
- Tyler Giles, Daniel Hungerman, Tamar Oostrom, Deaths of Despair and the Decline of American Religion, Journal of the European Economic Association, 2025;, jvaf048, https://doi.org/10.1093/jeea/jvaf048
Disclaimer:
This article is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your physician before making health decisions based on the TyG Index or other biomarkers.
© 2018 – 2025 Asclepiades Medicine, LLC. All Rights Reserved
DrJesseSantiano.com does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases
Discover more from Don't Get Sick!
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.